UNION, CASE, and Related Constructs

Type Resolution for UNION, CASE, and Related Constructs

If all inputs are of the same type, and it is not unknown, resolve as that type.

If any input is of a domain type, treat it as being of the domain's base type for all subsequent steps. [10]

If all inputs are of type unknown, resolve as type text (the preferred type of the string category). Otherwise, unknown inputs are ignored for the purposes of the remaining rules.

If the non-unknown inputs are not all of the same type category, fail.

Select the first non-unknown input type as the candidate type, then consider each other non-unknown input type, left to right. [11] If the candidate type can be implicitly converted to the other type, but not vice-versa, select the other type as the new candidate type. Then continue considering the remaining inputs. If, at any stage of this process, a preferred type is selected, stop considering additional inputs.

Convert all inputs to the final candidate type. Fail if there is not an implicit conversion from a given input type to the candidate type.

Example Type Resolution with Underspecified Types in a Union

SELECT text 'a' AS "text" UNION SELECT 'b';
 
 text
------
 a
 b
(2 rows)

Here, the unknown-type literal 'b' will be resolved to type text.

Example Type Resolution in a Simple Union

SELECT 1.2 AS "numeric" UNION SELECT 1;
 
 numeric
---------
       1
     1.2
(2 rows)

The literal 1.2 is of type numeric, and the integer value 1 can be cast implicitly to numeric, so that type is used.

Example Type Resolution in a Transposed Union

SELECT 1 AS "real" UNION SELECT CAST('2.2' AS REAL);
 
 real
------
    1
  2.2
(2 rows)

Here, since type real cannot be implicitly cast to integer, but integer can be implicitly cast to real, the union result type is resolved as real.

Example Type Resolution in a Nested Union

SELECT NULL UNION SELECT NULL UNION SELECT 1;
 
ERROR:  UNION types text and integer cannot be matched

This failure occurs because Tacnode treats multiple UNIONs as a nest of pairwise operations; that is, this input is the same as

(SELECT NULL UNION SELECT NULL) UNION SELECT 1;

The inner UNION is resolved as emitting type text, according to the rules given above. Then the outer UNION has inputs of types text and integer, leading to the observed error. The problem can be fixed by ensuring that the leftmost UNION has at least one input of the desired result type.

INTERSECT and EXCEPT operations are likewise resolved pairwise. However, the other constructs described in this section consider all of their inputs in one resolution step.

[10] Somewhat like the treatment of domain inputs for operators and functions, this behavior allows a domain type to be preserved through a UNION or similar construct, so long as the user is careful to ensure that all inputs are implicitly or explicitly of that exact type. Otherwise the domain's base type will be used.

[11] For historical reasons, CASE treats its ELSE clause (if any) as the “first” input, with the THEN clauses(s) considered after that. In all other cases, “left to right” means the order in which the expressions appear in the query text.